Table of Contents
Definition of Brain Death
Brain death is defined as the irreversible cessation of the brain and brainstem functions, regardless of their cause.
It is important to understand the physiologic difference between a deep coma and brain death. A deep coma is characterized by the failure of basic reflexes. Patients in a deep coma no longer perceive pain, and their breathing must be performed artificially.
Nevertheless, a coma can also be about disruptions of one or more brain centers. Some areas can be irretrievably ‘dead,’ whereas other areas are mentally alive. Brain death, or rather general brain death, is a coma with a complete failure of the functions of the cerebrum and the cerebellum. If both components fail, the patient is considered to be not conscious or unconsciously alive.
By this definition, particular nerve cells or smaller areas of the brain may be still active, but they cannot bring back the central nervous functioning of the brain.
Etiology of Brain Death
- Severe head injury
- Hypertensive intracerebral hemorrhage
- Ischemia of the brain
- Aneurysmal subarachnoid hemorrhage
- Some drugs, such as neuroparalytics and anesthetics, can cause changes in neurologic and neuromuscular function, as well as causing changes on electroencephalography (EEG).
Examination and Diagnosis of Brain Death
To undeniably identify the diagnosis of brain death in a patient, examination by two experienced physicians is required. To ensure an impartial decision, these physicians are not allowed to be part of the transplantation team.
Signs of brain death
- The pupils do not respond to light.
- There is no response to noxious stimuli, e.g., there is no blinking of the eyes on touching the surface of the eyeball.
- There is no gag reflex on touching the inner part of the throat near the uvula.
- The patient cannot breathe without being on a ventilator.
- The skin remains warm to the touch.
- The injection of atropine, 1–2 mg intravenously, will not increase the heartbeat by more than 6 beats per minute. This is due to the lack of stimulation of the vagus nerve.
Approach to brain death
1. Severe brain damage
2. Exclusion of other causes (e.g., intoxication, hypothermia)
Proof of symptoms:
2. Brainstem areflexia (e.g., pupil reflexes)
3. Failure of spontaneous breathing
Proof of irreversibility:
1. No change after 12–72 hours
2. Repetition of the proof of symptoms
Instrumental diagnostics (e.g., null lines on an EEG for 30 minutes)
If the patient is pronounced brain dead, there are three possible scenarios:
- The patient remains connected to the machines until natural death occurs.
- It is decided according to the patient’s living will or by relatives that the machines should be shut down.
- If the patient previously consented or the relatives consent to organ donation, the machines should remain switched on until the organs have been removed (organ explantation).
It is legally necessary to define brain death as a form of death. In order to remove donor organs from a person, the cardiovascular system must still be working; otherwise, within a short time, the liver, kidneys, and spleen can suffer damage because of the shortage of oxygen.
The following conditions may cause death without the heart stopping:
- Brain tumor
- Craniocerebral trauma
- Brain hemorrhage
Unfortunately, most accident victims have never made a statement about whether they would like to donate their organs after brain death. This makes the possibility of obtaining organs even more bleak. As the number of people awaiting a new organ increases, the problem continues to grow.
Many people do not completely trust the field of medicine. The idea that they might not be totally dead when the decision is made to harvest organs frightens them. In addition, there is strong opposition to the concept of ‘brain death,’ and the arguments are quite viable. The criticism encompasses religious concerns as well as medical doubts. Subsequently, two basic questions arise:
- Can brain death be considered as similar to death?
- Can brain death be undeniably diagnosed?
This is why it is important to understand the brain functions. For the family, observation of the Lazarus sign may be unwelcome. This sign occurs when spinal cord reflexes direct movement to the arms and legs. A sensitive explanation of the processes involved in this sign helps the relatives to understand and accept the irreversibility of brain damage.
In addition, it is possible for central nervous body regulations to continue in patients who are diagnosed as brain dead according to the processes outlined above. The body may sweat and digest, regulate body temperature, and fight viruses. Men diagnosed as brain dead can have an erection. Pregnant women in the brain-dead state are able to bear a stillborn baby, and the birth of healthy children has been documented in more than 10 cases.
It is difficult to accurately diagnose brain death. The Roman Catholic Church, therefore, demands a null-line EEG for 6 hours in order to produce a flawless diagnosis. Procedures such as the null-line EEG, magnetic resonance imaging (MRI), or angiography must be performed to separate out patients with only brainstem damage. The demand for the patient to be under anesthesia during organ removal “for safety” also seems to be reasonable.
It is hard to differentiate where life ends and death begins because there is no clear demarcation. Accepting brain death is especially difficult when someone close to us is affected. In the case of strangers, it may be easier to fathom.
Brain-dead patients whose organs are removed cannot feel pain. Whether they want to be alive in a brain-dead state or whether they would prefer to help someone else with their organs should, therefore, be determined when they are alive.