Duchenne vs. Becker Muscular Dystrophy

by Carlo Raj, MD

My Notes
  • Required.
Save Cancel
    Learning Material 2
    • PDF
      IRheumatology II 01 Muscle Pathology.pdf
    • PDF
      Download Lecture Overview
    Report mistake

    00:02 A major type of muscular dystrophy is called DMD, or Duchenne Muscular Dystrophy.

    00:08 It affects approximately 1 in 3,500 male births.

    00:14 Progressive weakness will begin early as we shall see, and by the time this young male reaches the age of 10 or 12, is already wheelchair bound.

    00:24 Why is that? Well this then goes back to you understanding the major protein that I just showed you—the anchor, one of the largest proteins that is coated for in our body, so when it’s so large, it's actually susceptible to mutations taking place.

    00:38 Now if, if, there is a mutation that is so severe in which that protein is truncated because of a frame shift, that dystrophin is completely deficient or not present at all in terms of functioning, then you’ve lost the anchor.

    00:55 Now if you remember that picture that I showed you, where that dystrophin was a proper anchor between your alpha and your beta dystroglycans with your actin intercellularly, and you no longer have that, how in the world are you supposed to have contraction in the skeletal muscle and the cardiac? You don’t. So keep those two in mind again, and hence, it was important for me to quickly walk you through a little bit of anatomy and a little bit of physio.

    01:22 Most common and most severe of the muscular dystrophies, it is complete deficiency of that functioning dystrophin and it’s on chromosome X.

    01:33 The majority of your patients will have an X-linked recessive issue, hence males will be affected obviously much more so whereas females could then going to have a trait.

    01:43 One third of your patients may have de novo mutation, and that mutation you must know, is a frame shift.

    01:50 Why must you know that? Well apart from the knowing that it’s important for Duchenne, what we’re going to do is, is we’re going to compare our Duchenne with Becker. In fact, when we go through our muscle pathology here in this discussion, we will be making a lot of comparisons between diseases, we’re making comparisons between Duchenne and Becker, and we’ll be making comparisons between, let’s say, myasthenia gravis and Lambert- Eaton Myasthenic gravis syndrome.

    02:17 So in Becker, it is non-frame shift type of mutation.

    02:22 In Duchenne, it could be frame shift mutation.

    02:27 One-third of your patients, it’s still a decent percentage of your patients, both however, Becker and Duchenne, could have and would have deletions.

    02:39 There’s absolutely no dystrophin, and as you would expect, elevated levels of creatinine kinase.

    02:47 So what about the ladies? Well, if it’s X-link recessive then it could be a carrier, a trait.

    02:54 There might be high levels of creatinine kinase and ultimately the organ to be susceptible to damage would be the heart in your young lady, cardiomyopathy, and as do patients who survive long enough.

    03:08 And that is the thing, that in a female carrier of Duchenne, X-link recessive, that ultimately it’s the heart that will then weaken to the point of dilated cardiomyopathy and fatality.

    03:22 In Duchenne Muscular Dystrophy, this child, a boy, born frame-shift mutation perhaps, X-link recessive, clinically manifests by the age of 2 to 3 years of age, has lost ability in the pelvic girdle to get himself up.

    03:41 This is the manner in which he does if you take a look at the picture here— crawl, and not only crawl, but because the patient now is not able to get up, has to then climb up on himself.

    03:53 This is then called, as we shall see, Gower’s sign.

    03:57 In the meantime, down in the calf, it looks as though that there is hypertrophy but it's pseudo.

    04:02 Remember, there is no dystrophin, how in the world are you supposed to have hypertrophy of the skeletal muscle? It’s not happening.

    04:10 So, therefore, what is giving this child’s calves this hypertrophic appearance? Pseudofat.

    04:20 Right? In other words, you have fibro fatty changes taking place so you can imagine now, as I shall show you, what your skeletal muscle fascicle should look like versus what color is fat when you do, let’s say, a stain on histology.

    04:36 Fat—it’s clear, vacuolating, correct? So could you imagine where you have muscle fiber that is then occupied by fat instead— fibro fatty change—we call this pseudohypertrophy.

    04:50 Now, the issue is there’s so much weakness taking place that maybe the diaphragm can’t function properly, so therefore, pneumonia is a possibility, and it’s so bad in the teens if it was to occur in DMD that the child may even then die secondarily.

    05:08 Now characterized by, I’ll show you histology coming up, in which the fascicles of your skeletal muscle are going to be in different sizes and shapes, and some are trying to desperately regenerate, successful? Most likely not.

    05:25 Gower’s sign is what I’m demonstrating here for you or should I say the picture is demonstrating for you, in which the child is trying to get himself up by climbing on himself.

    05:39 Here once again is the picture that I showed you earlier, and now with better understanding of what the disease is, with the better understanding in Duchenne, as to how that dystrophin anchor protein that you see there, you have issues with your alpha and beta dystroglycans and if you don’t have a proper bridge that’s taking place between the dystrophin and the actin, then that skeletal muscle or cardiac muscle is then prone to damage.

    06:07 Dystrophin with the largest proteins. Remind me again, what kind of mutation could be taking place de novo one-third of the time? Frame shift or non-frame shift? Frame shift resulting in truncated protein.

    06:20 Whereas in Becker, as we shall see, there could be non-frame shift, it can be non-truncated, it could have deletions in both, and X-linked in both.

    06:32 I told you that I’d show you a picture, a histologic picture where you have different sizes and shapes of the muscle and exactly what you see here upon cut section.

    06:41 In addition, you also find endomyosin connective tissue and the regeneration is what is being depicted here in the middle, desperate regeneration.

    06:50 And it’s the blue hue that you will observe in this histologic picture.

    06:57 Difficult to regenerate.

    07:02 Our next muscular dystrophy is Becker.

    07:05 Now the most common of the muscular dystrophy is Duchenne, and is the most severe, Becker however, is muscular dystrophy but it is less severe than Duchenne and the reason for that is because there is partial dystrophin functioning.

    07:22 So they’re similar. Deletion is found in both.

    07:26 What will you not find in Becker in terms of mutation? You will not find frame shift. It’s a non-frame shift mutation.

    07:34 Non-truncated protein.

    07:37 The function dystrophin will be produced in a little bit.

    07:41 I’m going to show you where the representation of dystrophin can be seen in labs.

    07:49 The age onset a little bit later whereas as I told you about in DMD, the presentation may start in as little as 2 to 3, here maybe about 8 to 25 and unable to walk definitely by the age of 25, is the most common presentation in Becker.

    08:07 So everything is a little bit delayed.

    08:10 The reason for that is because it’s not that you have no function of dystrophin, you have some functioning dystrophin.

    08:20 Here’s an important picture, the first picture here on the left, I need you to understand, its imperative muscular dystrophies.

    08:30 The 2 muscular dystrophies to be compared here will be Becker and will be Duchenne.

    08:36 Remind me again, in Duchenne, are you producing any dystrophin? No. Frame shift mutation? So what you’re seeing here, if you take a look at the normal above, is normal uniformed muscle fascicles.

    08:54 Uniform—not varying in sizes and shapes.

    08:58 If you take a look at the middle row on the left, you’ll notice DMD stands for Duchenne, you’ll notice that the outline here, take a look a little bit closer please, different sizes and shapes of your skeletal fascicles.

    09:14 Which you notice the very bottom here, compare your DMD Duchenne, with BMD which is Becker, you’ll notice that the Becker looks better than the DMD as in Duchenne, you’ll notice some of the muscle fascicles are not even present.

    09:30 The picture there is not as uniformed as what it is normally up above; however, with Becker, it’s trying to look like the normal control on top but you can’t in Becker because you have a deficiency but you still have some functioning dystrophin.

    09:51 Is that understood? That’s the picture on the left.

    09:54 Now the picture on the right will do the same thing.

    09:58 This time, we’ll take a look at the movement of your dystrophin.

    10:04 It’s the movement of dystrophin from one end to the other and dark bars that you see here then represent the supply of dystrophin in the particular patient.

    10:22 We have 3 patients here.

    10:24 So on the far right, you’re going to be focusing on the bar.

    10:27 Those bars then represent the amount of dystrophin that is present in your patient.

    10:33 The controlled patient, you’ll notice has a dark black bar.

    10:39 That represents normal dystrophin— do not worry about the number 427— understand that that then represents dystrophin.

    10:46 Remind me in Duchenne, do you have any dystrophin? You will not. Do you find any black bars in that column for DMD? Not at all.

    10:57 And remind me again, when does the onset of disease begin? Maybe about 2 to 3 years clinically, pelvic girdle and such, Gower’s and so forth.

    11:07 In Becker, take a look.

    11:10 In Becker there is some functioning dystrophin and there’s some abnormal dystrophin.

    11:17 This tries to look normal but can’t and here you have issues with non-frame shift and deletion taking place, it is X-linked, it could be X-linked as well.

    11:28 That is how you read these 2 pictures and compare your 2 major muscular dystrophies.

    About the Lecture

    The lecture Duchenne vs. Becker Muscular Dystrophy by Carlo Raj, MD is from the course Muscle and Soft Tissue: Pathology. It contains the following chapters:

    • Introduction to Duchenne Muscular Dystrophy
    • Introduction to Becker Muscular Dystrophy
    • Lambert-Eaton Myasthenic Syndrome

    Included Quiz Questions

    1. Duchenne muscular dystrophy
    2. Becker muscular dystrophy
    3. Polymyositis
    4. Dermatomyositis
    5. Poliomyelitis
    1. DMD is caused by a frameshift mutation, while the milder BMD is caused by a missense mutation.
    2. DMD is caused by a missense mutation, while the milder BMD is caused by a frameshift mutation.
    3. DMD is caused by a missense mutation, while the more severe BMD is caused by a frameshift mutation.
    4. DMD is caused by a frameshift mutation, while the more severe BMD is caused by a missense mutation.
    5. Both DMD and BMD are caused by frameshift mutations
    1. Duchenne muscular dystrophy
    2. Becker muscular dystrophy
    3. Poliomyelitis
    4. Polymyositis
    5. Myasthenia gravis
    1. Becker muscular dystrophy
    2. Duchenne muscular dystrophy
    3. Churg-Strauss syndrome
    4. Poliomyelitis
    5. Dermatomyositis
    1. A patient with BMD has more dystrophin than a child with Duchenne muscular dystrophy, but less dystrophin than an unaffected individual.
    2. Becker muscular dystrophy has an earlier onset than Duchenne muscular dystrophy.
    3. Becker muscular dystrophy is more severe than Duchenne muscular dystrophy.
    4. There is a higher level of dystrophin in a child with Duchenne muscular dystrophy than one with BMD.
    5. Dystrophin is absent in Becker muscular dystrophy.
    1. Heart
    2. Kidneys
    3. Spleen
    4. Brain
    5. Liver

    Author of lecture Duchenne vs. Becker Muscular Dystrophy

     Carlo Raj, MD

    Carlo Raj, MD

    Customer reviews

    5,0 of 5 stars
    5 Stars
    4 Stars
    3 Stars
    2 Stars
    1  Star